Niyyah Coffee
About This Spot
Stepping into Niyyah Coffee feels like discovering a quiet haven where every detail invites you to slow down and savor the moment. Tucked along the Nickel Plate Trail in Fishers, this coffee spot carries a gentle rhythm—calm and purposeful, yet welcoming enough for a solo stretch of work or a laid-back catch-up with friends. Its airy, thoughtfully designed space balances a modern aesthetic with touches that nod to tradition, setting the stage for a truly intention-driven experience.
The mood here is unhurried, with skilled baristas crafting each espresso-based drink with care, drawing from high-quality beans that gently sing through every pour. Whether you’re intrigued by the subtle warmth of a masala chai that hums with spice or tempted by one of their smooth lattes accented with hints of vanilla or cardamom, the menu feels like an invitation to explore familiar flavors in new, comforting ways.
Beyond the beverages, Niyyah Coffee offers light treats that pair beautifully with your cup—flaky croissants, delicate scones, or a famously rich biscoff tres leches cake that rewards those who linger. There’s an evident love for texture and balance here, whether in a cold brew’s crisp finish or the layered sweetness of a creme brulee latte. It’s a place that supports small indulgences, encouraging you to slow your pace and truly experience the simple joy of good coffee and thoughtfully prepared accompaniments.
Those who find their way here often return not just for the coffee, but for the quiet connections fostered within the space. Its serene yet spirited atmosphere holds the energy of a neighborhood spot where locals feel at ease, whether working by the window or sharing moments over a unique blend like the “layover” espresso with orange juice and sparkling lemonade—a clever twist that shows Niyyah’s playful side without overshadowing the craft.
With the nearby walking trail just steps away, it’s equally suited for a mid-hike pause or a morning ritual. Niyyah Coffee feels less like a stop on the map and more like a thoughtfully woven thread in the daily lives of those who cherish a slower, more mindful approach to their coffee break.
What’s Available Here
-
Outdoor seating - On-site services
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Great coffee
- Great tea selection
- Solo dining
- Good for working on laptop
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Coffee
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
- Toilet
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
- Casual
- Cosy
- Quiet
- Trendy
- Family friendly
- Groups
- University students
- Accepts reservations
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
- Good for kids
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- Parking
Location & Hours
| Monday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM | |
| Tuesday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM | |
|---|---|---|
| Wednesday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM | |
| Thursday | 07:00 AM - 07:00 PM | |
| Friday | 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM | |
| Saturday | 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM | |
| Sunday | 08:00 AM - 07:00 PM |
Guest Reviews
Share Your Experience
Related Listing
Recently Viewed Listing
Yuk Dae Jang Irvine
Jobos
The Coffee Depot
Mike's Pizza Westminster
M A 01 Dec 2025
Loved the space and the vibes, it’s a pretty place to sit, relax, work or catch up. The angry bee was delicious, perfectly spicy. The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars was they don’t have any plastic/to go silverware for the desserts. I didn’t have time to sit and enjoy it in house. So I had a beautiful cake teasing me all the way home.
Sam Mtshali 13 Nov 2025
A Delightful Experience at Niyyah Coffee! I recently visited Niyyah Coffee in Fishers, and it was a truly enjoyable experience. The coffee shop's intention-driven approach is reflected in every aspect, from the carefully crafted drinks to the welcoming atmosphere. Key Highlights: - Expertly Crafted Coffee: Each cup is made with intention and precision, using high-quality, medium-roast beans that bring out the perfect balance of flavors. - Unique Seating Areas: The shop features thoughtfully designed spaces, including a bar area for focused work and a cozy corner with couches for relaxed gatherings. - Delicious Signature Drinks: Be sure to try their Special Zebra Latte, Brown Sugar Shook, or Authentic Masala Chai, each made with love and care. - Perfect for Quiet Meetings: The shop's dead silence and lack of background music made it an ideal spot for focused conversations and productive meetings. What Sets Niyyah Apart: Intentional Atmosphere: The shop's design promotes community and connection, with a quiet atmosphere that fosters conversation and productivity. Recommendation: If you're looking for a coffee shop that serves more than just a great cup of coffee, Niyyah is the place to be. With its warm atmosphere and commitment to community, it's an excellent spot to relax, work, or connect with friends. The silence and lack of music make it particularly suitable for quiet meetings and focused conversations.
Nadia S 11 Nov 2025
I have been to Niyyah Coffee once and already love it. I tried their hot latte with vanilla syrup, and it was exactly how a good latte should be - smooth, perfectly balanced, and not overly sweet. They also have some fun seasonal drinks and food options on the menu, which I’m definitely planning to try next time. I couldn’t resist getting the Biscoff Tres Leches, and it was absolutely amazing! So soft, rich, and flavorful that it disappeared within minutes. I honestly wish I had grabbed a second one. There’s plenty of seating both indoors and outdoors, which is a big plus. And the best part? They’re open until 7 p.m. (and even 8 p.m. on some days). Most coffee shops in the area close way earlier, so this is perfect for that post-5 p.m. caffeine fix. The service was excellent as well. Overall, it’s a total hidden gem. Great coffee, great vibes, and a place I’ll definitely be going back to.
Jon Burd 26 Oct 2025
Quality Intelligentsia beans, skilled baristas, professional staff, nice aesthetic, and a great selection of seasonal and handcrafted drinks. I went for the "layover" drink and was pleasantly impressed. Admittedly not everyone can pull off the taste profile of an orange juice and espresso blend. And can I just say it is so fun to have an Arabic coffee shop close to home that supports the Muslim community? As a former coffee shop owner operating with Christian values in a predominantly Muslim context it is awesome to see the reverse here and welcome that to our community. Bravo guys! Update: We also loved the Strawberry Floral Sparkling Tea and Chocolate Covered Strawberry Latte. Very good!!
N Surabhi 21 Oct 2025
Very pretty ambience and highly recommended for working out. It’s located in the Hub & Spoke fishers with Nickle plate trail right outside. I tried their zebra lattevery comforting.
Christopher T 03 Oct 2025
Found using the google and glad we did! Friendly people and great service. Coffee was delicious. The cortado sampler was fun. Ask for the maple brown sugar. Definitely a place to visit next time we’re up here!